- Write by:
-
Monday, December 28, 2020 - 12:12:56 PM
-
533 Visit
-
Print
Mining News Pro - Researchers from the Carnegie Institution for Science and the University of Colorado Boulder are proposing a new “evolutionary system” of mineral classification that includes historical data and reflects changes in the diversity and distribution of minerals through more than four billion years of Earth’s history.
Diamonds are the inspiration behind the scientists’ proposal because even though many of them differ in both composition and genesis, they are all categorized as “diamonds” by the International Mineralogical Association’s Commission on New Minerals, Nomenclature and Classification.
This means that the historical context of the gems is left behind and this has become problematic for planetary scientists, geo-biologists, paleontologists and others who have to treat equally rocks that formed billions of years ago in space as the carbon-rich atmospheres of dying stars expanded and cooled or diamonds that formed 5,000 years ago when a large meteorite struck a carbon-rich sediment on Earth.
“We came together from the very different fields of philosophy and planetary science to see if there was a rigorous way to bring the dimension of time into discussions about the solid materials that compose Earth,” said Robert Hazen, one of the scientists involved in the study, which was published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
Hazen explained that the IMA classification system for minerals dates to the 19th century when geologist James Dwight Dana outlined a way to categorize minerals on the basis of unique combinations of idealized compositions of major elements and geometrically idealized crystal structure.
But this system, for example, defines quartz as pure silicon dioxide when actually every specimen of quartz contains imperfections or traces of its formation process that makes it unique.
Like diamonds, then, quartz and other minerals with distinctly different historical origins are lumped together while other minerals that share a common causal history are split apart.
“Differences in a diamond or quartz crystal’s formative history are critical,” said Carol Cleland, philosophy of science professor at CU Boulder and lead author of the study.
In Cleland’s view, the conditions under which a sample was formed and the modifications it has undergone “are far more informative than the mere fact that a crystal qualifies as diamond or quartz.” Thus, planetary scientists need a new system of categorizing minerals that includes historical “natural kinds.”
Because a universal theory of “mineral evolution” does not exist, creating such a classification system for geosciences is challenging. In consequence, the researchers propose a “bootstrap” approach based on historically revelatory, information-rich chemical, physical, and biological attributes of solid materials.
They believe that this strategy allows scientists to build a historical system of mineral kinds while remaining agnostic about its underlying theoretical principles.
“Minerals are the most durable, information-rich objects we can study to understand our planet’s origin and evolution,” Hazen said. “Our new evolutionary approach to classifying minerals complements the existing protocols and offers the opportunity to rigorously document Earth’s history.”
Short Link:
https://www.miningnews.ir/En/News/609862
The Senate voted Tuesday evening to approve legislation banning the import of enriched uranium from Russia, sending the ...
Canadian miner Barrick Gold on Wednesday beat first-quarter profit estimates on higher bullion prices and said it has ...
BHP Group can’t cherry pick Anglo American assets without paying a hefty premium, Anglo investors told Reuters, ...
The Biden administration is considering banning imports of enriched Russian uranium using executive authority as ...
When former boss Mark Cutifani left Anglo American Plc in mid-April 2022, things had rarely looked better for the ...
Marex Group Plc and a group of the London-based firm’s shareholders raised about $292 million in a US initial public ...
Australian miner Lynas posted a slump in third-quarter sales revenue on Wednesday, missing analyst expectations on the ...
The Democratic Republic of Congo’s government notified Apple Inc. of concerns that the company’s supply chain may be ...
India is in talks with several countries seeking partnerships for technical help on lithium processing, said four ...
No comments have been posted yet ...